Ace Payroll vs Frontier Software – how they compare for AU/NZ payroll

For: Payroll Managers, HR Leaders, Finance Directors|11 min read|Last updated: August 2026

This comparison is published by Affinity. Vendor information is based on publicly available sources. Contact each provider directly for their current capabilities.

Summary

Ace Payroll is a low-cost desktop payroll tool for small NZ businesses, now being decommissioned. Frontier Software is an AU/NZ HCM suite with payroll reach across 26 countries. Affinity is shown here as a separate column: an AU/NZ enterprise payroll specialist for organisations whose complexity is concentrated in Australia and New Zealand.

How Ace Payroll and Frontier Software differ

Frontier Software is an established AU/NZ HCM vendor with 40+ years of history and local offices in Auckland, Wellington, Melbourne and Sydney. Its ichris payroll engine covers 26 countries, and its modules span recruitment, talent, learning and HR, alongside HCI21 analytics and IWF21 workflow tools.

The core distinction for a buyer is what each platform was built to optimise for: Ace Payroll is a low-cost desktop payroll tool for small NZ businesses, now being decommissioned, while Frontier Software is an AU/NZ HCM suite with payroll reach across 26 countries. AU/NZ payroll sits within each vendor's broader focus rather than as the sole product, which is where a specialist platform like Affinity differs from both.

One further point matters for this comparison: Ace Payroll is being retired by its owner (see the FAQ below), which means organisations still on it face a mandatory migration rather than a discretionary choice.

Feature comparison

A neutral comparison of Ace Payroll and Frontier Software across payroll and workforce capabilities, with Affinity shown as a separate AU/NZ specialist column. Vendor capabilities should be confirmed directly with each provider.

Native / strong Available / partial Not offered

Capability	Ace Payroll	Frontier Software	AU/NZ specialistAffinity
AU award & EBA interpretation	Not offered: NZ-only product – no AU award functionality	Native / strong: Established AU/NZ award interpretation (ichris)	Native / strong: Configurable engine – modern awards, EBAs, shift penalties, allowance stacking
NZ compliance (Holidays Act, KiwiSaver, IRD)	Native / strong: Native IRD Payday Filing, KiwiSaver and ACC levies	Native / strong: NZ compliance (Holidays Act, Payday Filing) – depth to confirm	Native / strong: Purpose-built Holidays Act engine, KiwiSaver, Payday Filing, NZ team
STP Phase 2 & superannuation	Not offered: Not applicable – NZ-only, no STP	Native / strong: Supported	Native / strong: Full STP Phase 2 & super, Pay Day Super ready
Pre-payslip intelligence	Not offered: No AI/intelligence features found	Available / partial: HCI21 analytics (workforce trend analysis, not transaction-level pre-payslip checking)	Native / strong: Payroll IQ – anomaly & variance checking before the payslip runs
Global / multi-country coverage	Not offered: NZ-only	Native / strong: 26 countries (ichris)	Not offered: AU/NZ focus – not multi-country
Workforce management	Not offered: Basic leave calendar only – no rostering	Available / partial: Available	Native / strong: Integrated WFM with real-time labour costing
Delivery / managed payroll	Not offered: Self-managed desktop software only	Native / strong: Software licensing, hosted, outsourced payroll	Native / strong: SaaS, Supported & Fully Managed on one platform
Named local AU/NZ support	Native / strong: NZ 0800 helpdesk and local trainer network	Native / strong: Local offices – Auckland, Wellington, Melbourne, Sydney	Native / strong: Named AU/NZ contacts who know your configuration
Product longevity / active roadmap	Not offered: Decommissioned 1 April 2027 (MYOB-confirmed) – no further development	Available / partial: Not a stated focus – confirm directly	Native / strong: Independently owned; continuously invested for 40+ years – no sunset

Where Ace Payroll fits

Ace Payroll has historically suited very small NZ employers wanting a low-cost, simple desktop tool for IRD compliance rather than a full-featured platform. With MYOB decommissioning it on 1 April 2027, it is no longer a viable long-term choice – the practical question for remaining Ace Payroll customers is which platform to move to, not whether to move.

Where Frontier Software fits

Frontier Software is built for organisations that want a full HCM suite – payroll, recruitment, talent and learning – from a vendor with genuine long-standing AU/NZ offices and multi-country reach through its ichris platform. Its 40+ years of local history, 26-country coverage, and HCI21/IWF21 tooling make it a strong fit for organisations consolidating HCM breadth with a vendor that still has real local presence.

Where Affinity fits

For organisations whose payroll complexity is concentrated in Australia and New Zealand, a specialist engine with pre-payslip intelligence, delivery-model flexibility, local data residency, and named local support is a different proposition to either Ace Payroll or Frontier Software. Some organisations run Ace Payroll or Frontier Software for their broader positioning and Affinity for a complex AU/NZ operation; others choose Affinity specifically because they need genuine cross-Tasman depth that neither platform is built to prioritise.

Frequently asked questions

Is Ace Payroll or Frontier Software better for Australian payroll?

Ace Payroll is a low-cost desktop payroll tool for small NZ businesses, now being decommissioned. Frontier Software is an AU/NZ HCM suite with payroll reach across 26 countries. Which fits better for Australian payroll depends on which of those is closer to what your organisation actually needs. Confirm current AU award and EBA depth directly with both providers. For organisations whose complexity is concentrated in Australia and New Zealand, a specialist engine like Affinity is built specifically for that depth.

Do Ace Payroll and Frontier Software handle New Zealand payroll?

Ace Payroll: Native IRD Payday Filing, KiwiSaver and ACC levies. Frontier Software: NZ compliance (Holidays Act, Payday Filing) – depth to confirm. Confirm current NZ depth directly with each provider – Holidays Act, KiwiSaver and IRD payday filing all require genuine local engine work, not just tax-table updates. Affinity runs a purpose-built NZ payroll engine with 40+ years of Holidays Act experience and an NZ-based support team.

What is the main difference between Ace Payroll and Frontier Software?

Ace Payroll is a low-cost desktop payroll tool for small NZ businesses, now being decommissioned, while Frontier Software is an AU/NZ HCM suite with payroll reach across 26 countries. They overlap on core payroll compliance but differ in scope, ownership model, and the customer base each was built to serve.

How does Affinity compare to Ace Payroll and Frontier Software?

Affinity is an AU/NZ enterprise payroll specialist. It does not try to match Ace Payroll or Frontier Software on their own ground; it competes on depth of AU/NZ award and Holidays Act compliance, pre-payslip intelligence, delivery-model flexibility, local data residency, and named local support.

Why is Ace Payroll being retired, and what should I do?

Ace Payroll is a New Zealand-only, locally-installed desktop payroll application, owned by MYOB since 2015 and originally built in 1990 for small NZ employers. It handles IRD Payday Filing, KiwiSaver and ACC levies natively, priced on a flat-fee rather than per-employee basis. MYOB has confirmed Ace Payroll will be decommissioned on 1 April 2027, with customers directed to MYOB Business Payroll. If your organisation is still running Ace Payroll, treat this as a forced re-platforming project on a deadline, not a routine software update. It is a reasonable moment to evaluate options on their merits – including a specialist AU/NZ payroll platform like Affinity – rather than defaulting to whatever migration path is offered.

Compare other providersvs

Starting a payroll review?

Run it properly. The free guide defines what you need; the toolkit turns it into a scored brief you can send to every vendor.

Get the Free Guide(no email required)Get in Touch